Tuesday, December 27, 2016

A Translation of the Genesis Creation Myths

Genesis I
1. When the divine first began to create the sky and the land,
2. the land was abysmal and dismal with a darkness close upon the abyss, and wind from the divine was blowing close upon the water.[1]
3. and the divine said “a light should come to be,” and a light came to be,
4. and the divine saw the light, that it was good, and the divine made a division between the light and the dark,
5. and the divine called out to the light “hello Day”! and he called out to the dark “hello Night”! and when it was evening and then it was morning, it was the first day. ¶

6. And the divine said “an expanse should come to be in the middle of the water, and it should come about as division in between, water from water.”
7. And the divine fashioned the expanse, and it divided between the water that was above the expanse from the water that was below the expanse.  And when it was that way,
8. the divine called out to the expanse “hello Skies”!  And when it was evening and then it was morning, it was the second day. ¶

9. And the divine said “the water under the sky should remain together in one place, and dry ground should appear.”  And when it was so,
10. the divine called out to the dry ground “hello Land”! and to the collection of the water he called out “hello Seas”! And when the divine saw that it was good,
11. the divine said “the land should sprout vegetation, plants that yield seeds of its type, the tree that yields fruit for its type when its seed in it is in the earth.”  And when it was that way,
12. the land sprouted vegetation, plants that yield seeds of their type. And when the divine saw that it was good.
13. and it was evening and then it was morning, it was the third day. ¶

14. And the divine said “beacons should come to be in the expanse of the sky in order to distinguish between the day from the night, and they should come to be in order to be signals for the seasons and for the days and for the years,
15. and they should act as beacons in the expense of the sky in order to cast light on the land.”  And when it was that way,
16. the divine made the two big beacons, the bigger beacon in order to rule over the day and the smaller beacon to rule over the night, along with the stars.”
17. And the divine gave these to the expanse of the sky to cast light onto the land
18. in order to rule over the day and the night, and to distinguish between the light and the dark.  And when the divine saw that it was good,
19. and it was evening and then it was morning, it was the fourth day. ¶

20. And the divine said “the water should always produce flocks that breathe life, and flying things that fly over the land right in the expanse of the sky.”
21. And the divine made the big sea monsters and every moving thing that breaths life that the waters flocked with (to be) for their type, and every thing that fly with wings (to be) for their type.  And when the divine saw that this was good,
22. the divine blessed them and said “you should be productive and become many and fill up the water in the seas, and the things that fly should become many on the land.”
23. And when it was evening and then it was morning, it was the fifth day. ¶

24. And the divine said “the land should produce what breaths life (to be) for its type, herd animals and crawling animals, the things living on the land (to be) for its type.” And when it was that way,
25. the divine made a herd animal (to be) for its type, and every crawling animal (to be) for its type.  And when the divine saw that it was good,
26. the divine said “we should make a person with our appearance that looks like us, and they should rule over the fish of the seas, and over the things flying in the sky and over the land and over all the crawling animals that crawl on the land.” 
27. And when the divine made the person in his own appearance, he made them, the male and female, with the appearance of the divine. 
28. And when the divine blessed them, the divine said “you should reproduce and become many and fill up the land, and you should tread upon the fish of the sea and over the things flying in the sky and over every animal that moves on the land.”
29. and the divine said “pay attention, I am giving you every plant that yields the seeds of their type, the tree that yields fruit of its type, this should be your food,
30. and to everything of the land that breaths life and to every thing that flies in the sky and every crawling animal that crawls on the land and everything that breaths life I am giving every ripe plant in order to be its food.”  And when it was that way,
31. the divine looked at everything that he made, and it was actually very good.  And when it was evening and then it was morning, it was the sixth day. ¶
Genesis II.
1. And when the sky and the land and all the throng were finished,
2. on the seventh day when the divine finished the undertaking he had fashioned and rested from all the undertaking he had fashioned,
3. the divine blessed and fulfilled it because on it he rested from all the undertaking that the divine had fashioned. ¶
From The Annals of the Sky and the Land, [which says] about when they were created:
On the day Yahweh[2]                            made the land and the sky,
5.         before every field plant                        was there on the land,
            before every field plant                        had yet to grow forth.
            since Yahweh2 had not                        yet rained on the land,
            so no earthling had yet                        cultivated the ground.
6.         a cloud then arose up                          from off of the land,
            and it watered the whole                     of the face of the earth.
7. and Yahweh the divine (it says,)
molded an earthling                            from out of earth’s soil
he blew in his nostrils             the breathing of living
the earthling became                           then a spirit of living.

8. And Yahweh the divine planted a garden off from the east of the land of Gheden, and there he put the earthling that he modeled,
9. and out of the earth Yahweh the divine made every tree grow pleasing when you see it and good when you eat it, and in the midst of this the tree of lives and the tree of the knowing of good and bad,
10.       a river from Gheden flowed                to water the garden,
it divided from there                            it grew four heads there.
11.       The first one, called Pišon,                  surrounds all Chawilah, where gold is,
12.       that land’s gold is good                      where the pearl and the Onyx are.
13.       the second river’s Gichon                   it surrounds all of Kush-land,
14.       the third river’s Hiddeqel                    it flows to the east of Assur.
and the fourth river, that one is Prath.
15. And Yahweh the divine took the earthling and put him in Gheden’s garden to work its ground and to protect it,
16. and Yahweh the divine enjoined the earthling to tell him “you will actually eat [the fruits] of any tree in the garden,
17. from the Tree of Knowing the Good and the Bad you will not eat [its fruit], because the day you eat its [fruit] you will actually die,”
18. and Yahweh the divine said “the earthling is not suitable to be in isolation, I will fabricate a helper for him like counterpart to him.”
19. And Yahweh the divine modeled every living thing of the field and every winged thing of the sky, and he brought it to the earthling in order to see what he would say to it, and whatever he said to it, the spirit of life, he named it [that].
20. And the earthling called out names to every animal and every winged thing of the sky and to every creature of the field, and for the earthling he did not find a helper for him as his counterpart.
21. And Yahweh the divine caused a stupor to fall on the earthling, and he slept, and he took one of his sides and he closed the flesh up under it,
22. and Yahweh the divine formed the side he had taken from the earthling into a woman and he brought her to the earthling.
23. And the earthling said when this was formerly it was actually one of my bones and some of my flesh, to this one I will say “hello, woman,” because she was taken out of a man,
24. in this way a man leaves his father and mother and clings onto his woman and they turn into one flesh,
25. and the earthling and his woman were naked but not ashamed. ¶
Genesis III
1. The snake[3] was the smartest of all the things living in the field that Yahweh the divine made, and he said “is it really true that the divine said ‘don’t eat [the fruit] of any tree in the garden’”?
2. And the woman said “we eat the garden tree fruit,
3. but the fruit of the tree that’s in the center of the garden, the divine said ‘don’t eat that, if you even touch it, you’ll die.’”
4. And the snake said to the woman “of course you’re not going to die,
5. it’s because the divine knows that the day you eat it your eyes will open up and you will be like the divine, because you’ll know the good and the bad.”
6. And the woman saw that the tree was good for food and it was pleasing to look at, and she desired to investigate the tree,[4]  so she took some of the tree’s fruit and ate it, and she gave some to her man and he ate it,
7. and both of them had their eyes opened up so they knew that they were naked, and so they sewed together fig leaves and made skirts for themselves,
8. and they heard Yahweh the divine as he was walking in the garden to take the air,[5] and the earthling and his woman hid themselves from the faces of Yahweh the divine up in a garden tree.
9. And Yahweh the divine called out to the earthling and said to him “where are you?”
10. And he said “your sound, I heard it in the garden, and I was afraid because I was naked and I hid.”
11. And he said, “who told you that you were naked? the tree I taught you about not eating from, you ate from it?”
12. And the earthling said “the woman you gave to be with me, she gave it to me and I ate it.”
13. And Yahweh the divine said “what is this you did?” And the woman said, “the snake tricked me and I ate.”
14. And Yahweh the divine told the snake “because you did this, a curse is cast upon you [to bind you] from every beast and ever life form of the field,[6] go on your stomach and eat dirt every day of your life.
15. I will put hatred in between you and the woman and between your descendants and her descendants, and he will chafe your head and you will chafe his heel.”
16. And he spoke to the woman, “I will really increase the amount of your toil and child bearing, and when you will give birth to sons, it will be something to see, and you will long for your man, and he will be your master.”
17. And he spoke to the earthling, “because you listened to your woman’s voice, and you ate the fruit of the tree about which I gave you an order and said ‘you are not going to eat from it,’ a curse is cast upon you [to bind you] to the soil for what you have done, you will eat it with toil every day of your life,
18. and it will grow you thorns and brambles, and you will eat the plants in the fields,
19. and with sweat in your nostrils you will eat bread until you return to the ground, because you were taken from it and you are dirt and you will return to dirt.”
20. And the earthling called out the name of his woman “Livia,” because she was the mother of all lives.
21. And Yahweh the divine made the earthling and his woman outfits from animal pelts and he dressed them in these.

22. And Yahweh the divine said “look, the earthling became like one of us by coming to know the good and the bad, now he must not reach out his hand and take fruit from the Tree of Lives and eat it and live for eons.”
23. And Yahweh the divine sent him away from the garden in Gheden to be a servant to the ground that he was taken from,
24. and he drove out the earthling and had him pitch his tent to the east of the garden in Gheden, and he stationed cherubim and the fire of a sword that became a sentry for the way to the Tree of Lives.




[1] "Abysmal and dismal" represents the phrase tohu wa boho. The adjective tutu is cognate with the noun them in the next clause which is usually translated as deep, abyss (bel sim.).
[2] as elsewhere in Gen. II and III, yhwh ’lwhym, Yahweh the divine.
[3] or perhaps oracle.
[4] the verb stem hshkl has a basic transitive meaning of come to know, learn about, investigate.
[5] lruch hyyom, lit. for the breeze of the day.
[6] ’ruh min, cursed from, seems to imply a katadesmos, a binding spell.

Thursday, December 22, 2016

How do terms such as 'Left' and 'Right' relate to 'Liberal' and 'Conservative'?


A brief attempt to define some terms common in current political discourse.  Terms such as left and right are often correlated with, and very commonly substituted for terms such as liberal and conservative.  This happens in a way that often renders any subsequent discussion confusing and muddled.  Below are some provisional definitions, or better, descriptions intended to help clarify at least some of what I will likely say in the future.

Right:
-Religious: seeing religion as a stabilizing force.
-Puritan: isolational, seeing culture as an integrated whole, it should be stable, fixed, unchanging, traditional.
-Dichotomic: seeing the world in terms of clearly defined, often oppositional structures. Valuing clarity.
-Metaphysical: seeing non-physical (i.e., cultural, psychological, aesthetic), mental qualities as real and external, i.e., “in the external, physical world.”
-Litigious: seeing the law as an acceptable means not just for social, but for cultural and aesthetic control.
-Hierarchic: seeing hierarchies as real, and so as important and desirable structures, and elites as trustworthy models of ethical value.

Left:
-Areligious or even anti religious: seeing religion as a means of elite cultural control. Spiritual concepts when in place, are less well defined.
-Integrational and appropriative: seeing cultural forms as modular, and so cultural states as provisional and adaptable.
-Gradaional: seeing the world in terms of poorly defined structures better represented as spectra of possibilities. Valuing nuance.
-Materialist: non-physical aspects of life are constructs and idiosyncratic.
-Activist: seeing the law as a tool of elite control.
-Egalitarian: seeing hierarchies as oppressive, elites as untrustworthy, because they allow themselves to invent or abrogate ethical standards.

Conservative: change and difference are disruptive and potentially socially harmful; stability and tradition are idealized; a tree needs strong roots.
Liberal: change is unavoidable and often desirable; tradition is often stifling and favors elites; a shark must keep moving or die.


Note how the terms left and right defined here reflect a cluster of features. A prediction arising from this, is that not all individuals who identify as left or right  or who are so defined by others, will necessarily express all of the relevant features.  And this appears to be born out.

The two sets of oppositions, left/right and conservative/liberal as defined above seem to differ in an important general way, such that we can consider the conservative/liberal spectrum as a basically quantitative one, since it seems to relate to the degree to which change is valued, whereas the left/right spectrum, involving a number of parallel qualities, can be viewed as a qualitative spectrum.  A prediction arising from the definitions above is that we should be able to correlate the two spectra in such a way as to expect the possibility of finding individuals who identify as conservative leftists as well as conservative rightists, and liberal rightists as well as liberal leftists.  However, based on the above descriptions, we can see how the correlation and often the confusion between conservative and right, as well as liberal and left arises.  But it arises, not because of the two sets of ideas (left/liberal, right/conservative) are synonymous, but because they share important features.  Defining these terms as above (vel sim.) allows our discussion of these important positions to proceed without becoming hopelessly muddled and confused.